The importance of book reviews
Book reviews are critical not only to authors in sharing news about a published book but also to help readers navigate the offerings that arrive each season and find books that are “on the shelf” as backlists by their favourite or new authors.
In launching my first novel, I was both excited and daunted by the role that reviewers play. Is the book a good read, in general? Is the literary quality to the reader’s taste? Is the story likely to be one that will appeal to readers of a particular type or genre? What is the general impression by the public – thumbs up, indifferent, or thumbs down?
Looking over the first 50 reviews published for The Brantford Wagers, I admire the willingness of reviewers to express their true opinions. It is worrisome, yes. There is a tendency in social media for people to say whatever they want, perhaps without reflection on the impact their words can have. My first two reviews that came out were in the 3.5 zone and, while I expected to see a range of ratings, I was terrified that the early ones were going to set the tone – much like in a psychological experiment where the views of a few tilt the opinions of all. I soon relaxed, seeing the 5.0s and 4.0s that followed, and I appreciated each reviewer’s expressed opinion. Reviews are not within the author’s domain – this is the rightful territory of readers only. Authors can listen and learn, enjoy, laugh, or weep, but need to remain more of less out of the conversation.
Recently, though, I received a review directly by email. The review is from a friend and former colleague who is a published author and editor and an English professor with expertise in 19th century literature. Sue Sorensen attended my online launch as a guest and won a copy of the novel for acing the Regency period history quiz. I have Sue’s permission to share her impression, which is a highlight for me among reviews so far.
A short review of The Brantford Wagers
Nadine Kampen’s historical novel set in the Regency era is a well-constructed and highly entertaining story full of surprise and charm. The pages brim over with memorable characters: we meet catty gossips and social climbers familiar to readers of Jane Austen but also encounter roguish children and daring equestrians. Yes, Kampen knows the world of Austen and the book can be called a historical romance, but this is more refreshingly outdoorsy and not in the least sentimental. Thoughtfully, Kampen shows a keen appreciation of the limitations and restrictions for men as well as women in this class-bound era. Kampen’s sprightly and capable heroine, Clara Vincent, ultimately is presented with the dilemma of choosing between two handsome suitors, but happily Clara’s marital deliberations do not comprise her entire identity. The plot of The Brantford Wagers has more twists than you might expect; friendship, the strain of family loyalties, and firm principles are at the forefront of this compelling story, which offers convincing scenes of action and plenty of lively period details.
Sue Sorensen, author of A Large Harmonium
If you are interested in reading reviews from readers of The Brantford Wagers, as of the end of April 2022, there are 50+ comments published on various platforms, including:
BookBub (10)
Goodreads (20)
Amazon (22 – 15 US, 3 CA, 4 UK)
Book Sirens ARC reviews (20, published to various other reader platforms)
Discovering Diamonds Review
Kirkus Review
As a new author, I cherish each review as it is published. Here are a few condensed excerpts from reviewers:
‘If you like the genre and you like the queen of the genre – Jane Austen – you’ll have a great deal of fun with this.’ / Discovering Diamonds Review, 20220406
‘A slow-paced but clever pastiche that will appeal to Regency romance fans.’ / Kirkus Reviews, 20211209
‘A book that truly captures the Austen spirit…’ / Melodixin, 20220203
‘An entertaining and suspenseful tale.’ / KatieJ, 20220120
‘A traditional and lovely historical.’ / Chrystal Crossings, 20220204
‘A well written historical read. Great style of writing. A slow, simmering, drawn out (take your time) romance. It was engaging with excellent, rich, tanagable, complex characters and a great story plot! Read and enjoy!’ / mmosburn53, 202202
To those who are in the habit of sharing reviews about novels with the public, positive or otherwise, thank you. In the publishing world, you are the best guide for other readers. Your role is important. If you are new to sharing your view, just know that the reading world is ready and waiting to hear your perspective. Visit sites like Amazon, BookBub, and Goodreads, or in relation to my work, also consider using my comments section here on nadinekampen.com.
Your time is appreciated and your opinion matters.
